There is no statutory right in India for employees to work remotely. Prior to the Covid-19 pandemic, only a handful of organisations recognised and considered the option to work from home. Growing acceptance of remote and hybrid work models in India has been fuelled by the pandemic and employers have been revisiting Indian regulations to assess their applicability in remote working scenarios. There appears to be industry-wide acceptance regarding the adoption of remote and hybrid work models.
Flexible working arrangements and work rules
In line with amendments in 2017 to Indian regulations regarding maternity leave, women are permitted to work from home after their regular maternity break, in agreement with their employer and provided the nature of their work allows them to do so. India is in the process of consolidating its national labour laws into four labour codes, one of which is the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 (IR Code). Yet to take effect, the IR Code contains ‘standing orders’, which mandate employers of certain establishments to prescribe work rules for their workforce. A draft of the proposed standing orders proposed by the federal government allows work from home flexibility by employers in the services sector, subject to mutually agreed written conditions of employment between the employer and worker.
Although there is currently no legislation overseeing remote work, India’s central and state governments have released specific regulations and guidelines for employers whose employees work from home or remotely. Lately, employers have largely continued to implement flexible working models for ease of convenience for employees and, in some cases, as retention strategies. Organisations implementing remote or hybrid work models adopt specific internal guidelines on remote working.
Companies registered with the Indian Department of Telecommunications, Special Economic Zones in India and Software Technology Parks of India are required to comply with certain prescribed conditions for their employees to work from home.
Considerations for employers permitting remote working include productivity tracking, overtime compensation management, occupational health and safety measures, harassment concerns, new incidents of misconduct, business reimbursement and employee compensation obligations, and tax considerations.
Overtime considerations
Overtime compensation in India is dependent on several factors, for instance, nature of work performed, wages earned by employees and the Indian state where they are located. Eligibility and payment of overtime has become complex in the Indian remote working landscape, as employers continue to have diminishing visibility on an employee’s actual number of hours worked.
In several cases, employees choose to work from their home state as opposed to the state where the employer is located, creating ambiguity as to which state’s overtime laws would apply. To reduce ambiguity and potential risks, employers should clearly outline and publish overtime policies and practices and ensure that employees continue to remain tagged to one state - usually where the employer is located - to provide clarity on the laws which would apply to them.
Safety considerations
There are different specifications relating to health and safety measures under state-specific shops and establishments regulations, contract labour regulations and laws on employee compensation for injuries. Currently, there appear to be limited judicial precedents in India providing clarity on the application of these regulations to remote working employees. That said, India’s anti-sexual harassment law provides a wide definition of ‘workplace’ and covers an employee’s dwelling place or house. Courts in India have agreed that the term ‘workplace’ should not be limited in its interpretation to office premises alone and must be interpreted broadly to include spaces that are beyond the compound of a traditional workplace, ensuring a suitable atmosphere for employees. It is essential that employers update their policies and practices to address these legal considerations adequately.
Remote working scenarios are likely to introduce different forms of misconduct which would otherwise not have existed. Employers should revisit their conduct policies and practices to prevent possible incidents which are likely to amount to misconduct in a remote working scenario, such as unprofessional etiquette during audio-visual meetings and repeated instances of absenteeism or unavailability during work hours.
Compensation
Historically, Indian employers structured employee compensation models with the aim of incentivising employees to work more, and allowances for night shifts, travel and meals were common. With employees working remotely, several of these allowances may not be relevant and are likely to be redundant. In addition, employees are now required to self-invest and make the appropriate adjustments to be able to work from home. In this context, employers should re-examine their compensation structures to align allowances and other benefits payable to employees working remotely so that working remotely does not result in cost implications for employees.
Tax considerations
Employers permitting employees to work remotely outside India should also be mindful of potential ‘permanent establishment’ risks and related tax implications that are likely to be triggered because of remote working arrangements, depending on factors such as how long employees are based outside India. Tax evaluation of such arrangements - including the assessment of applicable double tax avoidance agreements between India and the country where employees would be working remotely – might be necessary.
For queries related to remote working in India, contact Gerald Manoharan and Sonakshi Das of JSA Law.